You just wrapped up a 20-minute coffee chat with a banker. The conversation went well. Now what?
This moment — the follow-up — is where most students either solidify the connection or let it quietly die. A great follow-up keeps the relationship warm, shows professionalism, and positions you for the ask you’ll eventually want to make. A bad follow-up (or no follow-up at all) wastes everything you just built.
In this post, I’ll walk through how to follow up after a coffee chat with a banker — including exact email templates, timing guidance, and how to keep the relationship alive over the long term.
Why the Follow-Up Matters
Let’s start with the “why,” because I’ve seen a lot of students skip this step or treat it as a formality.
Bankers are busy. They’re doing you a favor by taking 20 minutes out of their day. A thoughtful follow-up signals that you respected their time, paid attention during the conversation, and are the kind of person who follows through. That last part matters a lot in investment banking, where attention to detail and follow-through are core professional skills.
More practically: bankers talk to dozens of students throughout recruiting season. A specific, well-crafted thank-you makes you memorable. A generic one — or nothing at all — makes you forgettable.
Timing: When to Send the Follow-Up
Send your thank-you email within 24 hours of the conversation. Same-day is ideal if you can manage it. The longer you wait, the less genuine it feels and the more the conversation fades from their memory.
If the conversation happened on a Friday afternoon and you’re sending on Monday, that’s fine — just acknowledge it briefly if you want (“I wanted to make sure to follow up before the week got too busy”). Don’t overthink the timing, but don’t let days pass without sending anything.
The Thank-You Email Template
Here’s a template that hits all the right notes:
Subject: Thank You — [Your Name]
Hi [Name],
Thank you so much for taking the time to speak with me today. I really enjoyed hearing about [specific thing they mentioned — their career path, a deal they described, their view on the market, etc.]. It gave me a much clearer picture of [the group / the bank / the sector].
I took away a lot from our conversation, particularly your point about [specific insight or advice they shared]. I’ll definitely keep that in mind as I move forward in the recruiting process.
[Optional: one sentence about something you’re going to do as a result of the conversation — “I’m going to look into [resource they recommended]” or “I’m planning to reach out to [person they suggested].”
Thanks again for your time and generosity. I hope we can stay in touch, and I look forward to potentially crossing paths down the road.
Best,
[Your Name]
[School, Graduation Year]
[Phone Number] | [LinkedIn URL]
Keep it to three to four short paragraphs. The key is specificity — reference something real from the conversation. This is the single most important thing that separates a good follow-up from a generic one.
What Makes a Follow-Up Stand Out
Beyond the basic template, here are a few things that take a follow-up from good to great:
Reference a Specific Insight
If they gave you a specific piece of advice — “focus on your technical prep early” or “don’t underestimate the fit component” — call it out directly. It shows you were engaged, not just reciting a polished story on your end of the call.
Show You Took Action
If they recommended a resource, a book, or another person to speak with, mention that you’re following up on it. Even if you haven’t done it yet, saying “I’m planning to reach out to [person they mentioned]” shows initiative.
Add Value When You Can
If during the conversation they mentioned something they were interested in — a sector trend, a company, a topic — and you come across a relevant article or insight within the next few days, send it along with a brief note. This is a highly effective way to stay on the banker’s radar without being pushy.
Keep It Short
Resist the urge to write a long email. They don’t have time to read it, and a long thank-you can feel like you’re trying too hard. Four sentences to four short paragraphs is the sweet spot.
When They Offered to Introduce You to Someone
If the banker offered to introduce you to a colleague, follow up on that within the same thank-you email — or in a separate quick note shortly after. Here’s how to phrase it:
“Also, I really appreciated your offer to connect me with [colleague’s name]. I would love that introduction whenever it’s convenient for you. I’ve attached my resume in case it’s helpful for context.”
Don’t let this slip. Warm introductions are gold in IB recruiting, and if they offered it, they expect you to follow through.
The Long-Term Follow-Up: Staying in Touch Over Time
A single thank-you email is not a relationship. The real value of a coffee chat comes from staying in touch over the months between the conversation and when you actually need the referral or advice.
Here’s a simple system for keeping relationships warm without being annoying:
Touch Point 1: Thank-You (Within 24 Hours)
You’ve already done this. Good.
Touch Point 2: Recruiting Update (When You Have News)
When you receive an interview invitation — especially at their bank or a peer institution — let them know. This is natural, not pushy. It gives them a reason to root for you and potentially put in a good word with a recruiter.
“Hi [Name], just wanted to let you know I received an invitation to interview at [Bank] — I’m really excited about the opportunity. Your insights from our conversation have been incredibly helpful in my prep. Thank you again for your time and advice. I’ll keep you posted on how it goes!”
Touch Point 3: Offer / Outcome Update
When you land an offer — at their bank or anywhere else — send a brief note. People love hearing good news, and it closes the loop on the relationship in a positive way. This also keeps the door open for future mentorship and career advice.
Periodic Touchpoints
Every couple of months, if there’s a natural reason to reach out, do it. Their firm announced a significant deal? Send a brief congratulations. They were promoted (visible on LinkedIn)? Send a short note. There’s a sector development that’s relevant to what they told you about their group? Share it.
These small touchpoints cost you almost nothing and build relationships that compound over years.
What NOT to Do in Your Follow-Up
- Don’t ask for a referral in the thank-you email. It’s too soon and will come off as transactional. Let the relationship develop first.
- Don’t be generic. “It was great speaking with you, I learned a lot” with no specifics is forgettable. Reference the actual conversation.
- Don’t attach your resume in the initial thank-you unless they asked for it. It can feel presumptuous. Include it only if it’s relevant (like when following up on an intro offer).
- Don’t cc other people. Your follow-up should be one-on-one.
- Don’t follow up more than once if they don’t respond. If you send a thank-you and get silence, that’s okay. Don’t send a “just wanted to make sure you got this” follow-up — it’s needy.
Building Your Networking System
If you’re running an active networking campaign — which you should be during recruiting season — you need a simple system to track your conversations. A basic spreadsheet works fine: name, firm, date of chat, key notes from the conversation, follow-up dates, and status.
This lets you stay organized as the number of contacts grows and ensures no one falls through the cracks. I’ve seen students lose track of 20+ conversations and miss critical follow-up windows simply because they didn’t have a system.
For more on how to build a full networking strategy, check out our investment banking networking guide. And make sure your resume is ready to share when the time comes — our IB resume template is a great starting point.
A Final Note on Authenticity
All the templates and tactics in the world won’t replace genuine human connection. The best coffee chat follow-ups I’ve seen from students aren’t just technically correct — they’re warm. They reflect a real person who had a real conversation and is genuinely grateful for the time and insight they received.
Recruiting is a long process, and the relationships you build through coffee chats can last well beyond it. Treat every banker you connect with as a long-term contact, not just a stepping stone to an offer. That mindset shift will change how you approach every conversation and follow-up — and bankers will feel the difference.
If you’re looking for more help with the full recruiting process, explore our free resources and see what our students have achieved at our WSMM track record page.
Want Personalized Investment Banking Coaching?
Wall Street Mastermind has helped thousands of students land offers at Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, JPMorgan, and every top bank. If you want personalized coaching to break into IB, apply here to learn more about how we can help you.
